Sunlight rippling across clear blue water

Taligens Insight

How a Culture of Coaching Accelerates Strategy Execution

Up to 67% of strategies fail in execution — and the cause is almost never the plan. It's the conversations.

Leadership Development9 min read

The Real Barrier to Strategy Execution Isn't the Strategy

Most executives know the sobering statistic: up to 67% of well-formulated strategies fail in implementation [1]. The culprits are rarely flawed plans or insufficient resources. They are almost always human: misaligned priorities, eroded trust, siloed decision-making, and a workforce that has disconnected from the meaning of the work.

Here is the harder truth: the everyday conversations happening inside your organization right now are quietly determining whether your strategy succeeds or stalls. The questions your leaders ask, or don't ask. The feedback that gets spoken, or swallowed. The degree to which people feel safe enough to surface problems early. These aren't soft concerns. They are the invisible architecture of execution.

A culture of coaching is how you redesign that architecture intentionally.

What a Coaching Culture Actually Is

A coaching culture is not a training program or an HR initiative. It is a set of values, practices, and processes that make open dialogue, honest feedback, and high trust the default mode of operating — from the boardroom to the front line.

It is the difference between an organization where managers answer and one where managers ask. That distinction matters enormously. Leaders who have developed coaching capabilities don't just perform differently. They listen differently, and in doing so, they help their teams think more clearly, act more boldly, and align more naturally with strategic intent.

The numbers reflect this. The 2025 ICF Global Coaching Study — the largest of its kind, conducted with PwC — found that coaching has grown into a $5.34 billion global industry, with more than 50% of coaching clients now sponsored by their employers [2]. This is no longer a perk reserved for executives. It is a strategic investment that leading organizations are embedding throughout their leadership pipelines.

The Questions Worth Asking in Your Organization

Before deciding on a path forward, it is worth pausing on a few diagnostic questions:

Which of our long-term strategic objectives are at risk because our culture and our strategy are not yet in sync?
What does the way our leaders communicate, decide, and collaborate reveal about what our organization actually values, as opposed to what we say we value?
Where are the performance symptoms — in customer satisfaction, market share, budget overruns, or turnover — that might be pointing to a deeper cultural misalignment?
What would need to shift in how our people interact for our strategic priorities to take root?

What the Evidence Shows

The case for building a coaching culture has strengthened considerably in recent years.

31%of U.S. employees engaged in 2024 — a ten-year low (Gallup)

529%ROI from executive coaching, from productivity alone (Metrix Global)

28%increase in retention at companies that embed coaching

70%more manager confidence in coaching conversations (AstraZeneca)

On engagement. In 2024, U.S. employee engagement fell to a ten-year low, with only 31% of employees engaged. Global engagement dropped that same year, marking only the second decline in twelve years of measurement [3]. Within that picture, manager engagement has seen the steepest fall of any group, dropping nine points since 2022. This is not a workforce problem; it is a leadership practice problem. And coaching directly addresses it. Companies with strong coaching cultures report 62% employee engagement, substantially higher than the levels reported in broader workplace engagement studies [4].
On performance. A coaching culture is linked to a 26% increase in work quality and up to a 50% increase in productivity [4]. A widely cited Fortune 500 case study by Metrix Global found that executive coaching delivered a 529% ROI from productivity gains alone, rising to 788% when employee retention benefits were included. A separate global survey by PwC and the Association Resource Center found that coaching returns an average of seven times its cost [5].
On retention. With voluntary turnover rates exceeding 20% in roughly one-third of organizations [6], the cost of disengagement has become impossible to ignore. Companies that embed coaching consistently report a 28% increase in employee retention [4]. The Saudi Electricity Company's coaching program, now spanning 800 employees and 85% of the leadership pipeline, achieved 95% talent retention across the organization and 98% among leaders, alongside 22% more internal promotions among coached leaders [2].
On trust and the quality of conversations. At AstraZeneca, a structured coaching initiative changed not just what leaders did but how they spoke. The company's own measurement showed a 45% shift in positive mindset towards performance development, alongside a 70% increase in manager confidence in holding meaningful coaching conversations [7]. Trust, it turns out, is not built through values statements. It is built through conversations, practiced over time.

Where to Begin: A Simple, Practical Structure

Building a coaching culture does not require a wholesale transformation overnight. It requires a deliberate sequence of steps that reinforce one another:

Diagnose before prescribing.

Use cultural assessments, 360-degree feedback, and employee engagement surveys not simply as measurement tools, but as opportunities to open new conversations across levels of the organization. The act of asking — and genuinely listening to the answers — is itself a coaching act.

Identify the cultural levers that matter most to your strategy.

Not every element of culture requires attention at once. Focus on the specific dimensions — such as values alignment, team engagement, leadership behaviors, and cross-functional trust — that are most directly impeding your strategic goals.

Build coaching capability at the manager level.

The manager as coach is the most powerful and underutilized lever available to most organizations [3]. Meaningful feedback delivered consistently at the team level has a compounding effect on engagement, retention, and performance that no enterprise-wide program can replicate from the top.

Complement with executive and team coaching.

Individual executive coaching accelerates leadership effectiveness and models the coaching mindset for the broader organization. Team coaching addresses the relational dynamics and collective blind spots that derail cross-functional collaboration and slow decisions.

Track what matters.

Define success in terms of the business outcomes you are pursuing, not just satisfaction scores. Tie coaching investments to movement in retention, engagement, decision velocity, and strategic milestone achievement.

The Challenges Are Real, and Worth Confronting

Even with compelling evidence, several barriers consistently impede the development of coaching cultures:

Lack of genuine commitment from the top. A coaching culture cannot be delegated. When senior leaders model the behaviors — asking rather than telling, acknowledging uncertainty, inviting dissent — it gives the rest of the organization permission to do the same. When they don't, the initiative will remain a program rather than become a culture.
Confusing coaching with performance management. Coaching is not a corrective tool. Its power lies precisely in its developmental, forward-looking character. Blurring this line destroys psychological safety and makes honest conversation impossible.
Rewarding answers over questions. Most organizational systems — from hiring to promotion to meeting culture — still privilege the person who has the answer over the person who asks the better question. Shifting this default is slow, but it is where culture change actually happens.

The Invitation

Strategy execution is ultimately an act of collective meaning-making. It succeeds when the people doing the work understand why it matters, trust the people they work with, and believe their voice shapes what happens next. A coaching culture is the organizational practice that makes all of this possible — not as an ideal, but as a daily reality.

Ready to build the conversations your strategy depends on?

Set up a conversation with one of our partners.

Set up a conversation

References

[1] Balanced Scorecard Institute, “The Leadership Gap: Understanding Strategy Execution Failure” (2024), citing Harvard Business Review.
[2] International Coaching Federation and PricewaterhouseCoopers, 2025 ICF Global Coaching Study (released September 2025).
[3] Gallup, “U.S. Employee Engagement Sinks to 10-Year Low” (January 2025); Gallup, State of the Global Workplace 2025.
[4] Human Capital Institute and ICF, Building a Coaching Culture research series; figures summarized in ExecOnline, “How to Foster a Coaching Culture at Your Organization” (2024).
[5] Merrill C. Anderson, MetrixGlobal LLC, Executive Briefing: Case Study on the ROI of Executive Coaching; PwC and Association Resource Center Global Coaching Survey, cited by ICF (2024).
[6] HR.com, State of Employee Retention 2025-26 (October 2025).
[7] AstraZeneca, “Unlocking Potential Through Coaching Strategy” (2024); ICF Coaching Impact Award case studies.